Back to Blog

The Downfall of a Restaurant: A Leadership Deficiency

May 14, 2023

Restaurants are more than just places to satisfy our hunger. They are the epicenters of culture, conviviality, and creativity. They are where we gather to celebrate life’s milestones, discover new flavors, and connect with our communities. As such, it's a tragedy when these establishments falter, collapse, or disappear, not due to a lack of talent, vision, or culinary prowess but because of a deficiency in leadership.

In my years of experience both as a restaurant consultant and a restaurant owner, I've observed the industry from multiple angles. I've distilled this undeniable truth: The success or failure of any restaurant is invariably linked to the quality of its leadership.

The Recipe for Failure

A restaurant’s downfall is like a slow-cooked dish — it doesn't happen overnight. It begins with a pinch of complacency, a dash of poor decision-making, and a generous serving of ineffective communication. This recipe of deficiency, when left to simmer, becomes a potent brew of dissatisfaction and disengagement, both among staff and guests.

The facade may still gleam, but cracks start to show in the form of inconsistent service, dwindling patron numbers, and souring workplace culture.

And much like a bad dish, it's tough to swallow.

Leadership: The Missing Ingredient

The best restaurants are those led by individuals who understand that their role extends beyond the kitchen or the management office. They recognize that leadership is about people, not just products or profits. It's about creating an environment where everyone, from the waitstaff to the line cook, feels valued and inspired to deliver their best.

Leadership, in its essence, is the ability to inspire others to achieve shared objectives and instill a strong restaurant culture; I always emphasize the transformative power of empathetic, strategic, and communicative leadership.

Here is my list of guidelines you must implement if you what to reach your potential.

50 Restaurant Excellence Guidelines

Restaurant Excellence Guideline #1: Adopt a leadership style that inspires your team and nurtures their development.

Restaurant Excellence Guideline #2: Consistently strive to enhance your leadership prowess. Participate in workshops, peruse literature, and mingle with successful figures in your sector.

Restaurant Excellence Guideline #3: Construct a vivid and persuasive vision for your restaurant that your entire team can rally behind.

Restaurant Excellence Guideline #4: Diligently allocate your resources and time to the right personnel. The recruitment and effective training of suitable staff is critical.

Restaurant Excellence Guideline #5: Clarify your expectations. Every team member should comprehend the objectives of your restaurant.

Restaurant Excellence Guideline #6: Incorporate a precise costed schedule system that accurately mirrors your team's working schedule. Watch the overtime.

Restaurant Excellence Guideline #7: Ensure the establishment and comprehension of your restaurant's goals by your team. That means KPIs.

Restaurant Excellence Guideline #8: Establish a Minimum Performance Standard (MPS) for each role.

Restaurant Excellence Guideline #9: Maintain a well-documented policy with explicit consequences for every infringement.

Restaurant Excellence Guideline #10: Implement a managerial training program that grooms your team for a managerial role within three to six months.

Restaurant Excellence Guideline #11: Inculcate your restaurant's core values within your team.

Restaurant Excellence Guideline #12: Enable your team to make decisions independently.

Restaurant Excellence Guideline #13: Use a two-tier leadership model to foster a culture of responsibility.

Restaurant Excellence Guideline #14: Equip your team with strategies to handle challenging guests.

Restaurant Excellence Guideline #15: Regularly host a team meeting labeled the "Restaurant Excellence Review."

Restaurant Excellence Guideline #16: Hire for a positive attitude and impart the necessary skills through training.

Restaurant Excellence Guideline #17: Implement a system to monitor your team's performance.

Restaurant Excellence Guideline #18: Utilize a system to monitor your team's punctuality and attendance. Reward great behaviors.

Restaurant Excellence Guideline #19: Train your team members to handle high-traffic periods in the restaurant efficiently.

Restaurant Excellence Guideline #20: Make guest service training a top priority. The experience your patrons receive is critical to your restaurant's success.

Restaurant Excellence Guideline #21: Regularly innovate your menu. Keep your patrons interested by frequently evaluating and updating your offerings.

Restaurant Excellence Guideline #22: Invest in your restaurant's digital footprint. A captivating website and dynamic social media presence can draw more guests.

Restaurant Excellence Guideline #23: Master your restaurant's financial operations. Comprehending your finances can highlight areas for improvement and growth potential.

Restaurant Excellence Guideline #24: Create a pleasant work atmosphere. Satisfied staff deliver superior service, leading to content guests.

Restaurant Excellence Guideline #25: Absorb lessons from your competitors. Recognize their strengths and consider incorporating similar strategies in your business.

Restaurant Excellence Guideline #26: Regularly solicit feedback from your staff and guests for valuable insights.

Restaurant Excellence Guideline #27: Prioritize clear and consistent communication to prevent misunderstandings and promote alignment.

Restaurant Excellence Guideline #28: Stay adaptable. The restaurant industry is fluid, necessitating readiness to adapt and evolve as required.

Restaurant Excellence Guideline #29: Never halt learning. Keep abreast of the latest industry trends and best practices.

Restaurant Excellence Guideline #30: Craft a powerful brand identity to differentiate yourself from competitors and foster guest loyalty.

Restaurant Excellence Guideline #31: Maintain an efficient inventory management system to avoid food wastage and save costs.

Restaurant Excellence Guideline #32: Always envision the long-term future of your restaurant. Play the long game.

Restaurant Excellence Guideline #33: Express appreciation towards your staff. Acknowledge their efforts and reward them appropriately.

Restaurant Excellence Guideline #34: Always have a contingency plan. The restaurant business can
be unpredictable; unexpected occurrences like supply shortages, staff shortages, or even a pandemic can disrupt operations.

Restaurant Excellence Guideline #35: Develop a culture of accountability. Encourage your team to take ownership of their tasks and responsibilities.

Restaurant Excellence Guideline #36: Build strong relationships with your vendors and suppliers. A reliable network can provide you with quality products consistently.

Restaurant Excellence Guideline #37: Emphasize food safety and hygiene. A safe and clean restaurant environment is not just a necessity but a right of your guests.

Restaurant Excellence Guideline #38: Leverage technology. From point-of-sale systems to guest relationship management software, technology can help streamline your operations.

Restaurant Excellence Guideline #39: Make sustainability a part of your business model. It's not just good for the planet, but it can also appeal to the growing number of eco-conscious guests.

Restaurant Excellence Guideline #40: Always prioritize quality over quantity. It’s better to offer fewer menu items that are done excellently than numerous mediocre ones.

Restaurant Excellence Guideline #41: Promote teamwork. A cohesive team can deliver better service, resolve issues faster, and create a positive work environment.

Restaurant Excellence Guideline #42: Constantly assess and refine your restaurant's operational process for efficiency and effectiveness.

Restaurant Excellence Guideline #43: Cultivate a culture of guests-centricity. Remember, the guests are the heart of your business.

Restaurant Excellence Guideline #44: Ensure a balanced work-life ratio for your team. Overworked staff can lead to diminished productivity and high turnover.

Restaurant Excellence Guideline #45: Strive to exceed guests' expectations. Satisfied guests often become repeat guests and can be your restaurant's best marketing tool.

Restaurant Excellence Guideline #46: Carry out regular maintenance of your restaurant's physical premises. A clean, safe, and appealing ambiance is vital for the overall dining experience.

Restaurant Excellence Guideline #47: Be proactive, not reactive. Anticipate potential problems and have solutions ready.

Restaurant Excellence Guideline #48: Foster a culture of continual improvement. Encourage your team to always seek ways to enhance their performance, the service, and the guest experience.

Restaurant Excellence Guideline #49: Understand the importance of marketing and invest in it. It's not just about attracting new guests but also retaining existing ones.

Restaurant Excellence Guideline #50: Love what you do. Passion is contagious; it permeates your team, your service, and, ultimately, your guests.

These guidelines, when implemented diligently, can propel your restaurant toward excellence. Remember, the journey toward excellence is not a one-time sprint but a constant marathon.

Keep pushing, keep innovating, and stay hungry for success.


Join my tribe BEFORE your competition does!

Tips, tools, and the latest ways to help your restaurant break free from mediocrity delivered right into your inbox!

I hate SPAM too. I will never sell your information, for any reason.